Hope and Class Die Early Election Year Deaths
As someone who has managed, worked on, and volunteered for political campaigns, believe me, I understand one thing—it is all about winning.There is no Ms Congeniality Award. You win or you lose. Period.
But as much of a hard ass as I am about that, I also think campaigns are ultimately about what kind of locality, state, nation and democracy we want.
And as hard ass as I may be about winning, like many voters and citizens, I am also an idealist. I want intelligent campaigns. I want clean campaigns. I want campaigns that inspire. I prefer the politics of hope over the politics of fear.
Silly me.
And usually, I am bitching about the Republicans not adhering to these values. John Thune’s campaign smears Tom Daschle for being “a DC resident.” Bruce Whalen’s campaign tries to start an absurd pregnancy rumor about Stephanie Herseth. George Bush, the Vietnam combat avoider, Swift Boats John Kerry, a real war hero.
And on and on.
But I’m afraid it is my party—the Democratic Party—that has killed Hope and Class so early in this 2008 election.
Exhibit A is Sen. Hillary Clinton’s use of fear mongering about Sen. Barack Obama with the “3 a.m.” TV ad. Worse, though, is her belittling of Obama’s message of hope—the calculating pantsuited pol dismisses the young black Senator as a dreamer—and by implication—all of us—young and old, black and white, rich and poor—who support Obama and wish for hope and change in our politics.
It is cynical and disgusting—and as Rhode Island, Texas, and Ohio showed yesterday—apparently effective.
Exhibit B is Sen. Tim Johnson’s campaign and its strident pre-emptive attack on possible GOP U.S. Senate candidate Steve Kirby. Yes, I know, I’m good at calling folks like Steve crony capitalists. But the ferocity of the Johnson campaign’s preemptive strike on Kirby, in my recollection, is unprecedented in South Dakota politics. We normally have to get into the bowels of a campaign before such personal attack crops up.
The attacks are unseemly and nonsubstantive. They are the politics of personal destruction. It is “politics as usual.”
What really bothers me is that Tim Johnson is in no way like this personally. He is a kind, good humored, hard working, intelligent, and mild mannered man. This is not who Tim Johnson is. The attacks and other dirty tricks use up in nearly an instant all the good will he had acquired after coming back from near death.
And it all disengages the voters.
My wife Donna, also a big fan of Tim Johnson and the Johnson family, probably said it best when were discussing all this the other day.
“This type of politics just makes me sick,” she said.
Indeed.
And all for what? To try and scare off Steve Kirby, an intelligent and capable grown man who will make a reasoned decision about whether to run for the U.S. Senate? Does anyone believe Kirby will think twice just because he has to endure such childishness if he really wants to run for the Senate?
Get real. It’s frat boy crap.
I typically expect hope and class to die at some point in a major political campaign. I just never figured it would be my side wielding the knife so early in the process.
Photo: Add “hope killer” to Sen. Hillary Clinton’s resume. (wireimage.com photo)
Technorati Tags: Tim Johnson, Steve Kirby, Hillary Clinton, Bruce Whalen, Stephanie Herseth Sandlin, John Thune, U.S. Senate, Presidential election, 2008 election, hope, class
Posted on Wednesday, March 5, 2008
by
Todd Epp
in 2008 Election, 2008 Presidential Election, 2008 Senate Race, 2008 U.S. Senate Race
|
6 Comments

Reader Comments (6)
Todd,
Get Real. Its politics, not bean bag.
Kirby campaign has reserved a room at the downtown Holiday Inn for a monday morning announcement. You can whine about the Repugnicans Todd, but wait until Kirby unleashes $10 million against Tim.
Todd, don't let them get you down. Politics doesn't have to be so vile and I appreciate your willingness to join in the house cleaning.
By the way, I don't quite think Exhibit A is a great example. I think it wholly appropriate to try to distinquish her "git 'er done" message against Obama's "if we just hope and dream enough all will be better" message. Her inference that maybe Obama might be a Muslim was over the top. Just so the record is clear, I think that McCain matches up better against Obama and prefer him as an opponent.
DT, if I'm reading you correctly, are you implying that any dirty trick is ok if it prevents Steve Kirby from running? You just can't help justifying Todd and Corey's point can you?
I'm not sure you shouldn't be thanking the Johnson campaign for a preemptive shot at sparing us another Kirby run. As I recall, things had gotten pretty rough in the 02 gubernatorial primary with Kirby slinging lots of mud before being accused of "selling skin" and that was against a fellow Republican. Why should we believe an 08 Kirby run against a Democrat would be any more civil than 02?
Todd, I certainly empathize with your wish for cleaner, more substantive campaigns. For example, I don't see Kirby's wealth as a legitimate issue. However, his involvement with Collagenesis is another matter. It's an issue the brings into question what standards of ethics and decency guide Kirby in business and by small extension, politics. It's a factual part of Kirby's past and I see no reason the Johnson campaign and/or others should not remind voters of it.
Which is to say I wish you would quit lamenting whatever role the Johnson campaign might have had in recent attacks on Kirby. We--or at least I--don't know the exactly what the Johnson campaign did or did not do. Being apologetic simply adds legitimacy to those who want to believe the worst and are using Tim's perceived role as license to wage the nasty campaign they've been dying to launch all along.
Todd did you forget what the thune folks , did to Daschle blaming Tom for the 1.70 gas prices in 2004.Look at the prices to day 3.15 and see what Thune has done already.Thune evidently has more power he has only been a senator less than 4 years and it has almost doubled. I can hardly wait till sunmmer when these gas prices go to four bucks thanks John for watching out for the middle class.
Todd:
Your comments have reminded me as to how we became friends. You have the ability, unlike many on both the left and right, to call your boys on the carpet when they deserve it.
You and I don't always agree. OK, we almost never agree. But you always stick to your principles and I admire you for it! That's a rare quality in today's world, especially in politics.